All stories

'World is his oyster': new Derbyshire home and mentor offer Shoaib Bashir fresh

2 sources2 articles
The GuardianThe GuardianLoaded Language
89

'World is his oyster': new Derbyshire home and mentor offer Shoaib Bashir fresh start

England off-spinner spent the Ashes carrying drinks but is determined to win back place with help of Mickey Arthur A new season dawns and for Shoaib Bashir it represents a new beginning. Overlooked by England for the entire Ashes despite two years of investment, and having had a nomadic career up t

Loaded LanguageLoaded Language
two cricket tragics who spent the winter swapping WhatsApp messages about games on television

The word 'tragics' is emotionally charged Australian slang that frames the pair in an affectionate, fan-boy light where a neutral description of their communication would suffice.

Read Full Article
D
Daily MailFaulty Logic
74

Shoaib Bashir 'doing extra´ as he bids to become England´s...

Shoaib Bashir revealed he has spent much of his first few weeks at Derbyshire in the nets as he looks to give himself every chance of reclaiming his spot as England's first-choice spinner this summer. Despite being England's only frontline spinner in Australia, Bashir was overlooked during last win

Faulty LogicFaulty Inference
Bashir was plucked from obscurity by England two years ago and claimed 68 wickets in 19 Tests, backed by the management despite inconsistent displays and Jack Leach being preferred to him at Somerset.

The phrase 'backed by the management despite inconsistent displays' is an unjustified inferential claim that Jack Leach's preference at Somerset was the reason Bashir was retained, when the article itself does not provide evidence for this causal assertion.

Faulty LogicAuthority Appeal
Derbyshire head coach Mickey Arthur, who has overseen Australia, South Africa, Pakistan and Sri Lanka, waxed lyrical about his new arrival, at one point exuberantly describing him as a "national treasure".

The parenthetical listing of Arthur's coaching pedigree ('overseen Australia, South Africa, Pakistan and Sri Lanka') substitutes institutional authority for independent evidence of Bashir's talent.

Read Full Article

Value for value. If this tool is useful to you, help us keep it free for everyone.

Give Back